Showing posts with label Dublin agencies in decline. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dublin agencies in decline. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

My new adland manifesto. Sorta.


The ad agency as we know it: like many a good concept, it's bin-bound.


Many people I know are truly good at offline advertising. They produce some genuinely great work, some memorable, entertaining, thought-provoking, brand-building creativity for their clients. But ask them why their work slams into the glass wall when it comes to bringing that level of creativity to the online world and the fizz goes straight out of their bucks. Or maybe the bucks go out of their budget.

The manual is in Martian for a lot of agencies right now. The atmosphere is Martian. They are increasingly aware that clients need this work and are in many senses way ahead of them with their online familiarity and, more pointedly, their willingness to take work to digital specialists. So why the paralysis? The learning curve too steep? It's not. The public are driving social media, and they're doing it because linking and sharing have never been easier.

Clients meanwhile have very definitely decided not to place too many eggs in one basket. It used to be that you had an ad agency and a PR agency if you needed one. Back when I were a lad, the media department was in the attic or in the basement and toiled away thanklessly, until they got smart and decided to piss off and set up their own stand-alone media agencies from the late 80s on. The audacity! Some creatives ran with the ball at that point and set up their own outfits, delivering creative solutions only. The marketing-speak guffmeisters had no option really but to become that most maligned of c words, consultants. Fragmentation and reinvention, but at least it seemed driven by some entreprenurial chutzpah.

But things have gone much further now. Key agencies no longer think in terms of retainers for any client. That level of blind loyalty no longer exists, and this is, in Darwinian probability, no bad thing. Project by project, campaign by campaign, agencies have to fight for every month's work and justify every budget in a way we never dreamed of even in the 70s, when nobody had a pot to piss in or a window to pitch it from. I see several shark clients smelling the fear and cutting their way through the soft underbellies of once-were-fatter agencies. It's not edifying, because some very good people are getting stiffed along the way, but I console myself that Darwin was clued in all along, and this level of upheaval will result in a sleeker, more dynamic communications model for Irish companies.

Nonetheless, looking objectively from the outside, almost a year on since I went freelance, I can see scurrilous practice on behalf of some clients. (If the word clients even applies any more. In many cases I think it's now a misnomer.) They're using the difficulties of the times as a great excuse for swinging a not-always-justifiable axe. And in the meantime agencies are holding the inevitable at bay, until they hear about the results of that big pitch, or until that big retail client shuffles the core of its business to another media house, or the great and fearless international leaders decide to realign their local agency portfolio. That one, let me tell you from experience, sucks three-months-rotten eggs.

And the lay-offs continue, and the leaching of talent is ongoing, and the fear grows ever more palpable month by month. Adland is in the grip of it now. But you know what? That old Feel the fear and blah blah bullshit is utterly correct. Adland has no choice. The goalposts have moved. Hell, the entire game is over. Now what? New game, that's what.

Here's my new communications credo. Disregard it if you want to. I'm not particularly bothered. I believe it. That's why I wrote credo.

  • A massive disintegration is underway.
  • There is no going back to the days of Brett Easton Ellis-like excess.
  • An utterly realigned and forever fragmented adscape will follow.
  • A large serving of humility is being served to a lot of people at the top.
  • A new underclass of talented and unafraid people is rising.
  • The learnings of people who understand brands will NOT be lost.
  • Those who adopt the basic tenets of social media AND understand brands will thrive.
  • That thriving will not be to previous scales, but an altogether more modest beginning.
  • The web developers and digital experts already out there, who embrace and work with the best of those in offline adland willing to learn and happy to fuse their bank of brand understanding with newer media, will have the communications powerhouses of the future.

But first the pain.

Like the Wild West, anaesthetics are thin on the ground. I'd suggest clamping down hard on a piece of desk and watching some of the YouTube funnies. They can be ok.